Monday, July 19, 2010

Be careful what you ask for

For almost as long as I can remember there have been arguments against the electoral college, which gives the smaller states a more than proportional say in our national election for President. There is a reason for that. The Founding Fathers realized that straight majorities can be tyrannical, and they were right, as witness the passage of Obamacare.

Now we find out that Massachusetts is following the lead of five other states and determining that the votes of its electors must be cast for the candidate with the greatest popular vote, not the candidate the people of Massachusetts voted for, and certainly not the candidate the elector would consider the best candidate.

The reasons for the electoral college are now lost to most people because of the failure to properly teach history and civics. Students are no longer taught what the Constitution says and why. The reasons given for promoting this change are disingenuous at the least and most likely an outright lie.
Supporters of the change say that the current Electoral College system is confusing and causes candidates to focus unduly on a handful of battleground states.
The dynamics of pure majority rule mean that candidates will only focus on a few large, safe states, knowing that they will control the vote. What will happen is that we will become a permanently blue-state country, as the total votes of the red states will never equal those of the blue, whereas their total electoral votes would.

This is a profoundly fundamental change to our entire electoral process and needs to be stopped.

Comments:
Anonymous left five comments on this post. All of them appear to be copies of the talking points from the site arguing for simple majority election of the president. I have rejected all five, not because they dispute my position, but because they were 1) anonymous, and 2) were not the independent production of the commentor. They would have been posted if they were not anonymous.
 
Toto, formerly known as Anonymous,

You are still anonymous. Creating a blogger identity that is nothing but an empty name to try to get around the moderation is not particularly smart.

Your content is nothing but cut and paste talking points. I goggle the exact words and get multiple hits from multiple places on the exact same wording.

Either provide something real or go away. This blog is not a platform for position documents.
 
Post a Comment

<< Home

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?

Blog Directory - Blogged